What is the best fantasy football draft order? The best fantasy football draft order is one that is perceived as fair and exciting by all league members, ensuring maximum engagement throughout the season. This article will guide you through various methods for determining your fantasy football draft order, from the most basic to the most elaborate. We’ll cover everything from a simple random draft selection to more nuanced fantasy football draft method choices, with a special focus on the popular snake draft order.
Image Source: images.squarespace-cdn.com
The Importance of a Fair Draft Order
The draft is the bedrock of any successful fantasy football season. It’s where you build your team, make your gambles, and set yourself up for glory. If the draft order feels rigged or unfair, it can suck the fun out of the entire experience for some participants. A well-thought-out best draft order strategy can elevate league morale and foster a more competitive, engaging atmosphere. Think of it as the initial seeding that sets the stage for the entire competition.
Common Draft Order Methods
There are many ways to decide who picks when. Some are quick and easy, while others add a layer of pre-draft excitement. Let’s explore the most popular options.
1. Random Draft Selection (The Classic)
This is the most straightforward and often the fairest method. Everyone agrees that it’s completely random, leaving no room for suspicion.
How it Works:
- Gather all league members.
- Use a trusted random number generator or draw. Common methods include:
- Online Draft Order Generators: Many websites and apps offer a draft order generator tool. You input your league members’ names, and it spits out a random order. This is popular for its ease of use and verifiable randomness.
- Physical Ball Draw: Write each team’s name on a slip of paper, fold them identically, and place them in a hat or bowl. Each manager draws a slip to determine their draft position.
- Dice Roll: Each manager rolls a die. The highest roll gets the first pick, the second highest gets the second, and so on. Ties can be re-rolled.
- Coin Flips: For smaller leagues or to settle specific ties, coin flips can be used.
Pros:
- Simplicity: Easy to implement and understand.
- Perceived Fairness: No one can claim bias.
- Universal Application: Works for any league size or type.
Cons:
- Lacks Pre-Draft Excitement: Doesn’t add any extra fun before the actual draft.
- Potential for “Bad Luck”: You might draw the last pick repeatedly, which some managers find frustrating.
2. Last Year’s Standings (Reverse Order)
This method is popular in leagues that want to reward past performance but still introduce an element of randomness.
How it Works:
- The team that finished last in the previous season gets the first pick.
- The team that finished second to last gets the second pick, and so on.
- The team that won the championship gets the last pick in the first round.
This naturally sets the snake draft order where the standings are reversed in the second round. For example, if the order is 1-12 in the first round, it becomes 12-1 in the second round.
Pros:
- Rewards Failure (Kind Of): Gives those who performed poorly a chance to rebuild with high picks.
- Strategic Depth: Teams in the middle might have to strategize differently based on their projected draft slot.
Cons:
- Can Discourage Participation: If a team owner consistently finishes last, they might feel less invested.
- Less Random: Not entirely random, so some might find it less appealing.
- Not Applicable for New Leagues: Requires at least one prior season of results.
3. Keeper League Draft Order
In a keeper league draft order, the process is often tied to the players kept.
How it Works:
- Rounds for Kept Players: Before the main draft begins, teams select which players they are keeping.
- Draft Pick Compensation: The convention is that if you keep a player, you forfeit a draft pick from a certain round. The earlier you keep a player, the earlier the pick you lose.
- Example: Keeping a first-round talent might cost you your first-round pick. Keeping a seventh-round gem might cost you your seventh-round pick.
- Determining Remaining Order: The remaining draft slots are then determined through a random draft selection or by using last year’s standings.
Pros:
- Integrates Keeper Mechanic: Seamlessly blends player retention with the draft.
- Strategic Decision-Making: Forces tough choices about which players are worth giving up a high pick for.
Cons:
- Complexity: Can be more complicated for new leagues to grasp.
- Potential for “Gaming” the System: Experienced owners might find ways to manipulate keeper rules to their advantage.
4. Dynasty Rookie Draft Order
A dynasty rookie draft order is crucial for long-term league health. It’s often determined differently than a standard redraft league.
How it Works:
- Non-Roster Players: This draft typically involves only the incoming rookie class, not players already on teams.
- Common Determination Methods:
- Reverse Standings (Post-Season): Similar to redraft, the teams with the worst records get the earlier picks in the rookie draft.
- Trading Picks: Dynasty owners often trade future draft picks, creating a complex but dynamic draft order that shifts annually.
- Combination: Some leagues might use a weighted lottery system where teams that missed the playoffs have a higher chance of securing top picks.
Pros:
- Builds Long-Term Value: Allows teams to acquire young talent for sustained success.
- Trading Incentive: Encourages active trading of draft assets.
Cons:
- Requires Long-Term Commitment: Best suited for leagues dedicated to dynasty play.
- Complex Pick Management: Tracking traded picks can be challenging.
Adding Excitement: Pre-Draft Competitions
To make the draft order selection a bit more engaging, many leagues opt for pre-draft competitions. These add a fun, often humorous, element to the process.
1. The “Worst Team” Competition
This is a popular way to determine the first few draft slots.
How it Works:
- Last Place Punishment: The team that finished last in the previous season has the honor of picking first overall.
- Second-to-Last Picks Second: The team that finished second to last picks second overall, and so on, up to a certain point (e.g., the top 4 or 6 teams pick in reverse order).
- Randomness for the Rest: The remaining draft slots can be determined by a random draft selection.
Pros:
- Simple Integration: Easy to understand and implement.
- Motivational: Encourages even the worst teams to stay engaged.
Cons:
- Solely Based on Past Performance: Doesn’t involve any new activity.
2. Pre-Season Skill Challenges
These are fun, zero-stakes competitions that happen before the actual draft.
Examples:
- NFL Prediction Contest: Managers predict the winner of various NFL games during the preseason. The person with the most correct predictions gets the first pick.
- “Worst Prediction” Contest: Managers predict the player with the fewest fantasy points for a specific week. The manager closest to the actual outcome (without going over) gets a better pick.
- Trivia Contests: Fantasy football or NFL trivia questions are posed. Correct answers earn better draft slots.
Pros:
- Engaging and Fun: Adds a competitive element before the main event.
- Active Participation: Gets league members involved early.
Cons:
- Time Consuming: Requires organizing and running these mini-contests.
- Can Be Biased: If not structured carefully, some managers might have an inherent advantage (e.g., NFL knowledge).
3. The “Draft Lottery”
This is a slightly more involved method that incorporates chance and a bit of drama.
How it Works:
- Assign Lottery Tickets: Each team is assigned a number of “lottery tickets” based on their previous season’s performance.
- Example: Last place gets 12 tickets, second to last gets 11, and so on. The champion gets 1 ticket.
- Use a Lottery Ball Machine or Online Generator: A random number or ball is drawn from the pool. The team holding that ticket gets the first pick.
- Remove the Ticket: The drawn ticket is removed, and the process repeats until all picks are assigned.
Pros:
- High Drama: Creates excitement and anticipation.
- Balances Fairness and Chance: Still gives the worst teams a better chance but allows anyone to win.
Cons:
- Requires Setup: Needs a system for drawing tickets (physical or digital).
- Can Be Lengthy: The drawing process itself can take time.
Specific Draft Formats and Their Order Implications
The way your league drafts can also influence how the order is determined.
The Snake Draft Order
The most common fantasy football draft method is the snake draft. This is where the draft order reverses every round.
- Round 1: Team A picks 1st, Team B picks 2nd, …, Team Z picks last (12th).
- Round 2: Team Z picks 1st (overall 13th), Team Y picks 2nd (overall 14th), …, Team A picks last (overall 24th).
- Round 3: The order reverses again, mirroring Round 1.
Determining the Snake Draft Order:
The snake draft order is determined by the initial selection of the first round. Once that is set, the rest of the draft flows naturally from that order. Common methods for setting the first round include:
- Random Draft Selection: As mentioned earlier, a lottery or generator is used to decide the order of the first round.
- Reverse Standings: The worst team from last season gets the first pick.
Why it’s popular: The snake draft provides a sense of balance. While the teams picking at the turn (e.g., 1.01, 2.12, 3.01) get to pick players in rapid succession, they then face a long wait for their next pick. This system aims to mitigate the advantage of having consecutive picks.
Auction Draft Order
In an auction draft order, each team is given a fixed budget of fantasy dollars to bid on players. The draft order here refers to the order in which teams nominate players.
How it Works:
- Nomination Order: Typically, the order in which teams nominate players for auction is determined randomly at the start of the draft.
- Who Nominates First? This initial nomination order is usually set by one of the random methods described previously (lottery, generator, etc.).
- Subsequent Nominations: After a player is drafted, the team that nominated them typically cannot nominate again until all other teams have had a chance to nominate a player. This keeps the nomination process relatively balanced.
Pros:
- Strategic Depth: Nomination order is crucial. Nominating a top-tier player early can force opponents to spend big early, leaving them with less money for later.
- Dynamic: The draft is fluid and constantly changing.
Cons:
- Requires More Sophistication: Owners need to understand the implications of nomination order.
- Can Be Slow: Auctions can take significantly longer than snake drafts.
Mock Draft Order
A mock draft order is simply the sequence of picks used during a practice draft. While it doesn’t affect your actual league, practicing with a realistic mock draft order is invaluable.
How it Works:
- Most draft order generator tools or mock draft platforms will present a random snake or linear draft order for practice.
- You can often choose to simulate different draft positions to see how your draft strategy might play out.
Why Practice Matters:
- Test Strategies: See how different draft slots impact player availability.
- Identify Value: Discover players who fall to you in later rounds.
- Get a Feel for the Draft: Familiarize yourself with the flow and pace.
Choosing the Best Draft Order Strategy for Your League
The “best” draft order strategy is subjective and depends on your league’s preferences. Consider these factors:
League Size
- Smaller Leagues (e.g., 8-10 teams): Random selection or reverse standings work well. The impact of draft position is less pronounced.
- Larger Leagues (e.g., 12-16 teams): The difference between picking first and last is significant. Randomness or methods that offer a chance to move up are often preferred.
League Type
- Redraft Leagues: Focus on fairness and excitement for a single season. Random draws and reverse standings are popular.
- Keeper Leagues: Draft order can be influenced by keeper decisions, adding another layer of strategy.
- Dynasty Leagues: Long-term team building is key. Rookie draft order is often tied to reverse standings or involves complex pick trading.
League Vibe
- Serious Competitors: Might prefer methods that reward past performance or offer strategic advantages.
- Casual/Fun Leagues: Will likely gravitate towards the most entertaining and random methods, possibly incorporating pre-draft challenges.
Advanced Drafting Techniques and Order Considerations
Beyond simply determining the order, consider how your position affects your draft.
Picking at the Turn (e.g., 1.01, 2.12, 3.01)
- Advantage: You get two players back-to-back, allowing you to secure a pair of high-value players or reach for a player you really want without a long wait.
- Strategy: Can be great for targeting players with similar ADP (Average Draft Position) or grabbing a high-upside player and a reliable one.
Picking at the Ends (e.g., 1.01 or 1.12)
- Advantage (1.01): You get the consensus top player. You then have a long wait, so the strategy is to pick the best player available at each turn.
- Advantage (1.12): You get two players at the end of the first round and the beginning of the second round. This often allows you to get two high-value players who might otherwise be gone.
- Strategy: For the last pick, focus on value and position scarcity.
Picking in the Middle (e.g., 1.05, 1.06)
- Advantage: You are often insulated from the extremes. You get a good player without the long wait of the early picks or the compressed draft period of the turn picks.
- Strategy: Allows for a balanced approach, taking the best player available and not being forced into specific reaches or plays.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What is the most common fantasy football draft order method?
A1: The most common method is a random draft selection, often implemented using an online draft order generator or a physical draw, which then dictates the snake draft order.
Q2: Can I use a different method for each league I’m in?
A2: Absolutely! The beauty of fantasy football is its adaptability. You can choose different methods for different leagues based on the preferences of the league members.
Q3: How do I handle draft order if a new owner joins mid-season or takes over an abandoned team?
A3: Typically, a new owner would inherit the draft slot of the abandoned team. If a new owner joins before the draft, they should participate in the random draft selection process.
Q4: Is there a “best” draft order strategy for winning?
A4: While picking early (1.01) or at the turn offers advantages, there isn’t a universally “best” strategy. Many successful owners have won from all draft positions. The key is adapting your draft strategy to your specific slot.
Q5: How does auction draft order differ from snake draft order?
A5: In a snake draft order, it’s about the sequence of picks. In an auction draft order, it’s primarily about the order in which teams nominate players for bidding, which is usually randomized.
Q6: Should keeper league draft order be completely random?
A6: Not necessarily. Keeper league draft order often involves forfeiting picks based on which players are kept, so it’s a hybrid system that combines player retention decisions with a randomized element for the remaining picks.
Q7: When should I decide on the draft order method?
A7: Decide on your fantasy football draft method well before the draft itself. Communicate the chosen method to all league members to ensure transparency and avoid disputes on draft day. This is also a good time to discuss rules for tie-breakers or any special draft seeding considerations.
By carefully considering these methods and discussing them with your league mates, you can ensure your fantasy football draft is fair, exciting, and sets the stage for a competitive season. Whether you opt for a straightforward random draft selection or a more elaborate pre-draft competition, the goal is to maximize engagement and fun for everyone involved.