The question of how many bench players you should carry in fantasy football is a crucial one for success. While there’s no single magic number, a general consensus among experienced managers leans towards carrying 5-7 bench players in most standard redraft leagues, balancing upside with immediate needs. This number can fluctuate based on league size, scoring format, and your drafting philosophy.
Building a winning fantasy football team is a continuous process of strategic decision-making, from draft day to the final week of the regular season. A cornerstone of this strategy, and often a point of contention, is fantasy football bench spots. How you utilize these precious roster spots can be the difference between a championship trophy and a disappointing season. This guide will delve deep into the art and science of fantasy football roster construction, specifically focusing on optimizing your bench. We’ll explore the rationale behind different bench sizes, the types of players to target, and how to adapt your strategy throughout the season.
Image Source: miro.medium.com
The Core Purpose of Your Bench
Your bench isn’t just a holding pen for players who don’t crack your starting lineup. It serves several vital functions:
- Insurance Policy: Protecting yourself from the unpredictable nature of NFL injuries. A single significant injury to a key starter can derail your season if you don’t have adequate backup.
- Waiver Wire Insurance: Allowing you to stash players with upside who might break out or fill a void. This prevents you from having to drop a promising player to pick up someone from waivers.
- Bye Week Coverage: Ensuring you have viable starting options when your key players are on bye.
- Opportunity for Exploitation: Providing flexibility to capitalize on emerging waiver wire talent and make strategic trades.
Fathoming the Ideal Bench Size: A Balancing Act
Determining the optimal bench depth is a delicate balancing act. Too few bench players leave you vulnerable to injuries and bye weeks. Too many can lead to stagnant roster spots, preventing you from capitalizing on better talent available on the waiver wire.
Redraft League Bench Strategy: General Guidelines
In most 10-12 team redraft leagues with standard starting lineups (QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, TE, Flex, K, DEF), a bench of 5-7 players is generally considered ideal. This allows for:
- Depth at key positions: You can carry 2-3 running backs and 3-4 wide receivers on your bench, providing coverage for injuries and bye weeks.
- A backup QB/TE: If you draft an elite QB or TE, having a reliable backup can be crucial.
- A kicker and defense: While some managers forgo these on the bench, carrying them can be prudent, especially if you have a strong starting DST or kicker.
Factors Influencing Your Bench Decisions
Several league-specific and personal preferences can influence how many bench players you carry:
- League Size: In smaller leagues (e.g., 8 teams), you might get away with a slightly smaller bench as player availability is higher. In larger leagues (e.g., 14-16 teams), you’ll likely need a deeper bench due to the scarcity of talent.
- Scoring Format: PPR (Point Per Reception) leagues often value wide receivers and pass-catching running backs more, potentially influencing your bench composition.
- Roster Size: The total number of players on a roster directly impacts how many bench spots are available.
- Your Draft Strategy: If you heavily invest in high-upside players early, you might need more bench spots to stash them. If you focus on safe, reliable options, you might need fewer.
Key Bench Archetypes: Who to Stash and Why
Not all bench players are created equal. Your bench should be a curated collection of players who offer specific benefits:
1. The “Handcuff” Player: Insurance for Your Stars
Handcuff players fantasy football refers to the direct backup of your team’s starting running back. If your starter gets injured, their primary backup often sees a massive volume increase, becoming a valuable fantasy asset.
- Why handcuff? It’s a low-risk, high-reward strategy. You’re essentially drafting a player who is likely to be a low-end starter or even bench fodder if your starter stays healthy, but could become a league-winner if disaster strikes.
- Targeting handcuffs: Look for the direct backup of your own starting running back, especially if your starter has a history of injuries or plays a position with high physical wear and tear. Also consider backups of other high-volume running backs, as they might have standalone value if they play in an offense that favors a committee.
- When to avoid: If your starter is incredibly durable, or if their backup is a very limited player with little standalone value, the draft capital might be better spent elsewhere.
2. The “Late-Round Sleeper”: Hidden Gems with Upside
Late-round sleepers fantasy football are players you can acquire in the later rounds of your draft who have the potential to outperform their draft position significantly. They often possess the talent, opportunity, or scheme fit to become fantasy stars.
- Why target sleepers? They offer tremendous value and can be difference-makers for your team. Finding even one reliable sleeper can elevate your roster.
- Where to find them:
- Talented players on bad offenses: A gifted receiver on a struggling team might see increased targets as the season progresses.
- Players returning from injury: If a talented player is recovering from a significant injury and falls in the draft, they can be a steal.
- Offensive line improvements: A strong offensive line can boost the production of running backs.
- Coaching changes: New schemes can unlock the potential of existing players.
- Identifying sleepers: This requires research into team situations, player usage, and potential breakout candidates. Look for players with athletic measurables, proven college production, and clear paths to opportunity.
3. The “Waiver Wire Pickup” Prospect: Pre-emptive Stashes
These are players who are currently unrostered or on the fringes of fantasy relevance, but who possess the potential for a significant role change or breakout performance. You stash them on your bench, waiting for an opportunity to arise.
- Why stash waiver wire pickups? This proactive approach allows you to secure valuable talent before it becomes widely available. It’s about anticipating future needs and opportunities.
- Who to target:
- Backup running backs to injury-prone starters: Similar to handcuffs, but you might target these players even if they aren’t the direct backup, if they have a clearer path to volume.
- Receivers in situations of uncertainty: If a starting receiver is on the trading block or facing legal trouble, their backup could be a prime stash candidate.
- Tight ends on teams with poor starting options: A talented but raw tight end could emerge as a valuable option.
- Players with a history of high target share or volume: Even if they are currently underperforming, their underlying usage metrics can indicate future success.
- The “Add/Drop” Game: Be prepared to cut players who don’t pan out to make room for new waiver wire pickups.
4. The “Bye Week Coverage” Player: Ensuring Week-to-Week Consistency
These are players who fill in for your starters during their bye weeks. While not as exciting as sleepers or handcuffs, they are essential for maintaining a competitive edge throughout the season.
- Why carry bye week coverage? You don’t want to be forced to start a player with a very low ceiling simply because your starter is inactive.
- Targeting bye week coverage:
- Backup RBs/WRs on your own team: If you have multiple starters at a position, their backups can serve this purpose.
- Players with mid-season bye weeks: Identify players whose bye weeks are staggered from your key starters.
- “Low-end Flex” options: Players who are unlikely to win you a week but can reliably put up 8-12 points.
Drafting for Depth: A Prudent Approach to Roster Construction
Drafting for depth means prioritizing solid backups and players with upside at key positions, even if it means sacrificing an elite option at another position. It’s about building a resilient roster that can withstand the inevitable ups and downs of a fantasy season.
Early Rounds: Balancing Stars and Depth
- Targeting your core: Secure your top players at positions of strength.
- Considering positional scarcity: If you’re in a league where elite RBs or WRs are scarce, you might need to prioritize them.
- Identifying high-upside backups: Even in early rounds, consider players who have elite upside if their starter were to miss time.
Mid-Rounds: Filling Out Your Starters and Bench
- Securing starting-caliber players: Aim to fill out your starting lineup with reliable options.
- Identifying potential bench stars: Target players with a clear path to significant playing time or a breakout.
- Acquiring handcuffs: This is a prime time to grab the backups of your already drafted star running backs.
Late Rounds: Swinging for the Fences
- Late-round sleepers: This is where you take shots on players with the potential to become league-winners.
- High-upside backups: Look for players who could step into larger roles due to team situations or talent.
- Drafting a second QB/TE: If you didn’t address these positions early, now is the time to grab a solid backup.
Roster Management: The Key to Sustained Success
Roster management is the ongoing process of evaluating your team, making waiver wire moves, and optimizing your lineup. Your bench plays a critical role in this.
The Waiver Wire: Your Lifeline
The waiver wire is where champions are often made. Your bench depth directly impacts your ability to take advantage of waiver wire opportunities.
- Dropping players: Having a clear understanding of who is expendable on your bench is crucial. Avoid sentimentality. If a player isn’t producing or showing signs of improvement, don’t hesitate to cut them to pick up someone with more upside.
- Adding players: Your bench allows you to stash players you want to add from waivers without immediately dropping a player from your starting lineup. This is especially important if you have a high waiver priority or are trying to acquire a player in a FAAB (Free Agent Acquisition Budget) auction.
- FAAB Strategy: When bidding on waiver wire pickups, consider the long-term implications. Is this a player who could be a starter for the rest of the season, or a one-week fill-in?
Trade Strategy: Leveraging Your Bench
Your bench players can be valuable trade assets.
- Trading depth for upgrades: If you have excess depth at a particular position, you can package those players to acquire a high-end starter or fill a glaring need.
- Acquiring handcuffs: You might need to trade a bench player to get the handcuff you desire.
- “Buy Low” opportunities: If a player on your bench is underperforming but has a good track record, you might be able to package them in a trade to acquire a player who is currently undervalued.
Bye Week Strategy Fantasy Football: Proactive Planning
Bye week strategy fantasy football involves anticipating and preparing for the weeks when your key players will be inactive.
- Identify bye weeks early: As soon as the NFL schedule is released, mark down the bye weeks for your drafted players.
- Prioritize bye week coverage: In the mid-to-late rounds of your draft, consider players whose bye weeks complement your core players.
- Target players with flexibility: If you have multiple players with the same bye week, consider dropping one in favor of a player with a later bye.
- Waiver wire during bye weeks: During bye weeks, the waiver wire can be a goldmine as teams drop players to make room for fill-ins.
Common Bench Mistakes to Avoid
Even with a solid strategy, it’s easy to fall into common traps when managing your bench:
- Hoarding too many low-upside players: Owning multiple players who have minimal potential for growth or increased opportunity.
- Dropping potential breakouts too early: Giving up on a player who might be a few weeks away from a significant role change.
- Holding onto injured players with no hope of return: Unless it’s an IR (Injured Reserve) spot, it’s often better to cut your losses.
- Neglecting positional scarcity: Not having adequate backup options at positions where injuries are common (e.g., RB).
- Being too rigid: Not adapting your bench strategy as the season progresses and new information becomes available.
Putting It All Together: An Example Roster
Let’s imagine a 12-team redraft league with a 16-player roster. A balanced bench might look like this:
| Roster Spot | Player Archetype | Rationale |
|---|---|---|
| Bench RB 1 | Handcuff RB | Direct backup to your starting RB. High upside if starter misses time. |
| Bench RB 2 | High-upside RB | Young RB with a potential role increase or in a committee that could become a lead back. |
| Bench WR 1 | Solid WR2/3 | A reliable receiver who can fill in for bye weeks or injuries, offering consistent low-to-mid scoring. |
| Bench WR 2 | Late-round Sleeper WR | A receiver with speed or a good target share potential who could break out. |
| Bench WR 3 | Emerging Waiver Wire Pickup | A player showing increased targets or who is the next man up due to injury on another team. |
| Bench TE/QB | Backup TE/QB | A solid backup for your starting TE or QB, especially if they are injury-prone or have a tough schedule. |
| Bench Flex/RB | Additional Depth/Handcuff | Another RB with potential value or a player at a position you want extra depth in. |
This example includes 7 bench players, providing ample coverage and upside. The specific players will vary wildly based on your draft and waiver wire activity.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: How many bench players should I have in a 14-team league?
In a 14-team league, given the increased scarcity of talent, you’ll likely want to lean towards the higher end of the bench spectrum, aiming for 6-8 bench players. This provides necessary depth in a smaller player pool.
Q2: What if I play in a keeper or dynasty league?
Keeper and dynasty leagues require a significantly different fantasy football roster construction approach. Bench spots are far more valuable as they are used to stash promising young players and potential future stars. You might carry 8-10+ bench players in these formats, prioritizing long-term upside and potential.
Q3: When is it okay to drop a bench player?
You should consider dropping a bench player if:
* They have not shown any signs of improvement or increased opportunity after several weeks.
* Their starting player has returned from injury, diminishing their value.
* A more promising player is available on the waiver wire.
* They are your third or fourth backup at a position where you already have strong starters and depth elsewhere.
Q4: How important are handcuffs in fantasy football?
Handcuffs are very important, especially for running backs. While they might not produce if your starter stays healthy, they offer significant upside if an injury occurs. They are a form of drafting for depth that can save your season.
Q5: Should I always carry a backup QB?
This depends on your league and your drafting strategy. If you draft an elite QB like Patrick Mahomes or Josh Allen and believe they are unlikely to miss significant time, you might opt for more bench depth at other positions. However, in leagues where QB scoring is highly volatile or where backup QBs are scarce, carrying a reliable backup is a wise move for roster management.
Q6: How do I balance drafting for immediate production vs. bench upside?
This is a constant tension. Generally, in the early rounds, you want to prioritize players who offer a high floor and ceiling. As you move into the mid-to-late rounds, you can afford to take more shots on players with high upside but lower floors, effectively building your bench with these types of players.
By thoughtfully constructing your bench, you create a more robust and adaptable fantasy football team, better equipped to navigate the challenges and seize the opportunities that arise throughout the season.