Penalties are declined in football for several key reasons, including the offense of the penalty not being committed, a penalty on the opposing team, or the penalty being offset by another infraction. What happens when a penalty is declined? When a penalty is declined, it essentially means the play that occurred before the penalty flag was thrown is accepted, and the penalty itself is ignored by the offended team.
Football, a game built on precision and adherence to a complex rulebook, often presents situations where a penalty flag is thrown, only for the potential punishment to be rescinded. This can be a source of confusion for fans and players alike. Why does this happen? It’s not simply an arbitrary decision by the officials; rather, it’s a consequence of intricate rules governing rule infringements, fouls, and the subsequent reasons for nullification. This deep dive aims to unravel the various scenarios and underlying principles that lead to a penalty being declined in American football.
Image Source: www.the-sun.com
The Mechanics of Penalty Declination
When a penalty flag is thrown by an official, it signifies a potential rule infringement by one of the teams. The severity of the infraction, the specific rule broken, and the game situation all play a role in how the penalty is handled. However, the ultimate decision on whether to enforce the penalty or decline it rests with the team that was wronged by the illegal actions.
The Offense Declines the Penalty
The most common reason for a penalty declination is that the offended team chooses not to accept the penalty. This decision is strategic and is made based on the outcome of the play itself.
Situations Favoring Declination
- Positive Play by the Offended Team: If the team that was subjected to the penalty still managed to achieve a highly advantageous outcome on the play, they might decline the penalty. For instance, if a defensive holding penalty is called against the defense, but the offense completes a long touchdown pass, the offense will almost certainly decline the penalty. Accepting the penalty would negate the touchdown and likely result in a much smaller gain (or even a loss of down in some cases).
- Minor Infractions with Minimal Impact: Sometimes, a penalty called might be very minor and have little to no impact on the play’s outcome. The offended team’s coach might instruct the captain to decline it to avoid disrupting the flow of the game or to prevent a more critical penalty from being called on a subsequent play due to the officials being hyper-vigilant.
- Field Position: While less common, if a penalty offers a less desirable field position than the result of the play, it might be declined. For example, a penalty for illegal contact during a punt might give the receiving team a short gain and a better field position than if they accepted the penalty which might push them back further.
Penalties Offset by Infractions on the Other Team
Another frequent reason for penalties being declined involves simultaneous or near-simultaneous rule infringements by both teams. In such cases, the penalties are said to “offset.”
The Double Penalty Scenario
When both teams commit a penalty on the same play, the officials must determine if the penalties offset.
- Offsetting Penalties: If both teams commit fouls that carry an equal number of penalty yardage, or if the nature of the fouls is such that they cancel each other out according to the rules, then the penalties are offset. In this scenario, neither penalty is enforced, and the result of the play stands. For example, if the offense commits holding and the defense commits pass interference on the same play, these penalties would typically offset.
- Non-Offsetting Penalties: Some fouls are considered “personal fouls” or “flagrant fouls” and are not subject to offsetting. If a personal foul occurs by one team and a less severe foul occurs by the other, the personal foul penalty is usually enforced, and the lesser penalty is disregarded.
Officiating Errors and Incorrect Calls
Despite the best efforts of officials, officiating errors can and do occur. Sometimes, a penalty flag is thrown based on an incorrect perception of an event.
When Flags Fly Incorrectly
- Misinterpretation of Rules: Officials are human, and while highly trained, they can occasionally misinterpret a specific rule or its application in a dynamic game situation. This can lead to an incorrect call being made.
- Misidentification of Players: In the heat of the action, an official might mistakenly identify the player who committed the infraction.
- Judgment Calls: Many penalties in football are judgment calls. For example, pass interference or holding can be subjective. What one official sees as holding, another might see as legal blocking. If the head coach or captain believes the call was a clear error in judgment that negatively impacted their team, they might not accept it.
The Review Process
In modern football, particularly in leagues like the NFL, certain plays are reviewable. This review process can also lead to penalties being overturned or declined.
- Instant Replay: If a penalty is called on a play that is subsequently reviewed and the review shows no foul occurred, the penalty will be nullified. This is a crucial mechanism for correcting officiating errors.
- Challenges: Coaches can challenge certain calls. If a challenge is successful and overturns the initial call, any penalty associated with that call is declined.
Player Misconduct and Illegal Actions
Beyond standard gameplay penalties, there are also infractions related to player misconduct and outright illegal actions that can affect penalty enforcement.
Beyond the Scope of Typical Fouls
- Unsportsmanlike Conduct: While often penalized with yardage, if a team commits an act of unsportsmanlike conduct but the opposing team scores a touchdown on the same play, the touchdown will stand, and the unsportsmanlike conduct penalty might be declined.
- Intentional Grounding: If a quarterback intentionally grounds the ball to avoid a sack, a penalty is usually assessed. However, if the pass was nearly complete to an eligible receiver, or if the team gained significant yardage on the play, they might decline the penalty.
- Illegal Equipment or Formation: Certain rules govern player equipment and team formations. Violations of these rules can result in penalties, but these are typically enforced in a straightforward manner unless a specific game situation dictates otherwise.
Specific Scenarios Leading to Declination
Let’s explore some concrete examples of how penalties are declined, categorizing them by the nature of the infraction and the subsequent decision.
Offensive Penalties Declined
- Offensive Holding on a Touchdown Play: If the offense scores a touchdown but there was a holding penalty on an offensive lineman, the defense will almost always decline the penalty. Accepting it would negate the touchdown and likely result in a loss of yardage and possibly a loss of down, which is far less desirable than scoring.
- False Start on a Big Gain: A false start penalty moves the ball back five yards and results in a loss of down. If the offense breaks a long run or pass for a touchdown despite the false start, declining the penalty is the obvious choice.
- Intentional Grounding vs. Completion: If a quarterback is about to be sacked and throws the ball away, it’s intentional grounding. However, if the ball inadvertently lands near an eligible receiver, or if the team gains substantial yardage on another part of the play (e.g., a penalty on the defense during the same play), the offense might decline the grounding penalty.
Defensive Penalties Declined
- Defensive Pass Interference on an Incomplete Pass: If the defense commits pass interference but the pass is incomplete, the offense has a decision. They can accept the penalty (which results in automatic first down and yardage) or decline it and essentially replay the down. If the incomplete pass was a deep ball that was slightly overthrown, and the potential gain was significant, they might decline it to try the same play again.
- Holding on a Defensive Sack: If a defender sacks the quarterback but was also flagged for holding, the offense will usually accept the penalty. However, if the sack itself resulted in a turnover (e.g., a fumble recovered by the defense), they might decline the holding penalty to secure the turnover.
- Offsides on a Missed Field Goal: If the defense is offsides during a field goal attempt, and the kick is missed, the offense can choose to accept the penalty (moving them five yards closer for a much easier kick) or decline it. They would almost always accept it. However, if the kick was somehow successful despite the offsides, they might still decline the penalty to keep the points on the board. This is rare, as the kick would likely be replayed.
The Impact of Penalty Flags and Officiating Decisions
The presence of penalty flags is a constant visual cue that something has gone awry. The decision to throw a flag initiates a complex process, and the subsequent declination of that penalty is a strategic maneuver within the framework of the game’s rules.
When Flags are Thrown, But Not Enforced
- The ‘Aborted Play’ Scenario: Sometimes, an official might throw a flag, but the play is quickly blown dead before any meaningful action. For instance, if the quarterback drops the snap and the ball is immediately recovered by the defense, and a flag was thrown for something minor (like a procedural penalty on the offense), the defense might decline it to take possession of the ball.
- Dead Ball Fouls: Fouls that occur after the whistle or before the ball is snapped are called dead ball fouls. If a dead ball foul occurs on one team and the other team then commits a live ball foul, the live ball foul is usually enforced. For example, if a player on the defense taunts an opponent after a play, and on the very next play, the offense commits holding, the holding penalty would be enforced, and the taunting penalty might be declined by the offense (though typically, the offense would want the penalty enforced).
Reviewable Plays and Their Influence
The introduction of reviewable plays has added another layer to penalty declination.
- Challenging Calls: Coaches can challenge certain calls. If a defensive holding penalty is called, and the coach believes it was a clean play, they can challenge it. If the review shows no holding, the penalty is declined, and the coach retains their challenge. This is a critical tool against incorrect calls.
- Automatic Reviews: Some plays, like scoring plays or turnovers, are automatically reviewed. If a penalty flag is thrown on a scoring play, but the review shows that the penalty negated a touchdown that should have stood, the penalty will be nullified.
Factors Influencing the Decision to Decline
The decision to decline a penalty is rarely made in a vacuum. Several factors are weighed by the coaching staff and the player on the field making the decision.
Strategic Considerations
- Game Situation: The score, time remaining, and down-and-distance are paramount. A penalty that might be advantageous in one situation could be detrimental in another.
- Momentum: Coaches may decline a penalty to keep momentum going if their team is playing well or has just made a significant positive play.
- Avoiding Future Penalties: Sometimes, a team might decline a penalty to avoid drawing further scrutiny from officials, especially if they are already on thin ice regarding penalties.
Player Action and Communication
- Captain’s Role: In American football, one or two players are designated as captains and are responsible for communicating with the officials. They relay the coach’s decision or make an on-field judgment call if instructed to do so.
- Verbal Cues: Coaches often use hand signals or verbal cues to indicate whether to accept or decline a penalty.
Common Misconceptions about Declining Penalties
It’s important to differentiate between declining a penalty and a penalty being nullified due to an error.
- Declined vs. Nullified: A declined penalty is a choice made by the offended team. A nullified penalty is when the penalty is overturned by the officials themselves (e.g., due to a review or a mistake in the initial call).
- The “No Play” Scenario: Sometimes, a penalty might be declined because the play itself was essentially a “no play” due to a severe error, like a fumbled snap recovered by the defense behind the line of scrimmage. In this case, accepting a penalty on the defense might be less beneficial than taking possession of the ball.
Understanding the Officials’ Role
Officials are the arbiters of the game, and their flags initiate the penalty process. However, they are not the ones who ultimately decide whether a penalty is enforced if it is declined.
The Authority of the Captain
- On-Field Decision Maker: The designated captain on the field is the one who informs the referee of the team’s decision to accept or decline the penalty. They typically receive instructions from the sideline.
- Discretion in Certain Situations: While most decisions are coached from the sideline, in extremely fast-paced or confusing situations, a captain might have a small degree of on-field discretion.
The Language of the Referee
When a penalty occurs, the referee will announce the foul and the team that committed it. After the captain confers with the sideline, the referee will then announce whether the penalty is accepted or declined. For example, “Defense, number 75, holding. Offense declines.” or “Offense, number 62, false start. Accepted.”
The Nuances of Penalty Enforcement
The rules governing penalties are intricate and designed to maintain fairness and competitive balance. The ability to decline a penalty is a strategic element that adds another layer of depth to football.
Table: Common Penalties and Reasons for Declination
| Penalty Type | Common Offense | Typical Reason for Declination by Offense | Typical Reason for Declination by Defense |
|---|---|---|---|
| Offensive Holding | Lineman holds defender during a play. | Offense scores a touchdown or gains significant yardage on the same play. | Not applicable (this is an offensive penalty). |
| Defensive Holding | Defender grabs an offensive player. | Not applicable (this is a defensive penalty). | Offense gains significant yardage or scores a touchdown despite the holding. |
| Pass Interference | Impeding a receiver’s ability to catch. | Offense completes a much longer pass or scores a touchdown on the same play. | Offense completes a much longer pass or scores a touchdown on the same play. |
| False Start | Offensive player moves before the snap. | Offense breaks a long run or pass for a touchdown. | Not applicable. |
| Offsides | Defensive player crosses line before snap. | Offense scores a touchdown or gains significant yardage on the same play. | Offense gains significant yardage or scores a touchdown despite the offsides. |
| Intentional Grounding | QB throws ball away to avoid a sack. | Team gains significant yardage or scores a touchdown on another part of play. | Not applicable. |
| Unsportsmanlike Conduct | Taunting, excessive celebration, etc. | Team scores a touchdown or makes a crucial play despite the conduct. | Team makes a crucial play or scores a touchdown despite the opponent’s conduct. |
Reviewable Plays and Incorrect Calls
The NFL’s replay system has significantly impacted how officiating errors are handled.
- Pass Interference Reviews: In seasons past, pass interference was reviewable. If a pass interference penalty was called, and a coach challenged it, a review could lead to the penalty being overturned (declined).
- Holding on Sacks: If a sack occurs, but a holding penalty is also called on the defense, the offense will typically accept. However, if the sack resulted in a turnover, the offense might decline the penalty to secure the ball.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What happens if both teams commit a penalty on the same play?
If both teams commit a penalty on the same play, the officials will assess both penalties. If the penalties offset (usually based on yardage or specific rule exceptions), neither penalty is enforced, and the result of the play stands. If the penalties do not offset, the penalty on the team that committed the more severe infraction (often a personal foul or flagrant foul) is enforced, and the lesser penalty is disregarded.
Q2: Can a team decline a penalty if it would give them a first down?
Yes, a team can decline a penalty even if it would result in a first down. This decision is purely strategic. If the play resulted in an even greater gain or a touchdown, declining the penalty would be the obvious choice.
Q3: How do officials decide when to throw a penalty flag?
Officials throw penalty flags based on their observation of rule infringements and illegal actions during the game. This includes infractions like holding, pass interference, false starts, offsides, and unsportsmanlike conduct. Many of these are judgment calls, meaning different officials might interpret borderline plays differently.
Q4: What is the difference between a declined penalty and a nullified penalty?
A declined penalty is a choice made by the offended team not to enforce the penalty after it has been called. A nullified penalty is when the penalty itself is overturned by the officials, often due to an officiating error or a successful challenge during replay review, meaning the penalty flag was thrown incorrectly.
Q5: Who makes the decision to decline a penalty on the field?
The decision to accept or decline a penalty is typically made by the head coach on the sideline, who then communicates this decision to the designated team captain. The captain then relays this decision to the referee.
Q6: Are there any penalties that cannot be declined?
In most football leagues, any penalty can technically be declined by the offended team. However, it is almost always in the team’s best interest to accept a penalty that provides a significant advantage (like a touchdown or a first down) and decline one that offers a lesser benefit than the result of the play.
Q7: What are “reviewable plays” in the context of penalties?
Reviewable plays are specific aspects of a game that can be challenged by a coach or automatically reviewed by officials using instant replay. If a penalty is called on a reviewable play, and the review overturns the call, the penalty is nullified and therefore effectively declined. This mechanism helps correct officiating errors.
This comprehensive examination of why penalties are declined in football highlights the strategic depth and intricate rulebook that governs the sport. From advantageous play outcomes to the correction of incorrect calls, the decision to decline a penalty is a critical component of football strategy.